Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move? - Defamer Comments

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

SavannahR8 — Mon, 12 May 2008 04:37:03 PDT

The global sexualisation of pre-teens & teen is very disturbing. It's all way too much pressure for very young girls to be dealing with, where will it all end? Girls trying to look 30 and 30year olds trying to look 13. It's all so wrong.

SavannahR8

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

mrtrailsafety — Sat, 03 May 2008 10:03:16 PDT

Disney's not called "Duckau" and "Mouschwitz" for nothing.

mrtrailsafety

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

JacobFreeze — Sat, 03 May 2008 01:40:04 PDT

@Honeybhind: Exactly right about Grand Theft Auto and the National Program for All Teens Everywhere...

Lots of bangbang, but no kisskiss.

JacobFreeze

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

gawksFromaRock — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 16:49:44 PDT

Bunch of fuckin Puritans, still, 250 years later.

gawksFromaRock

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

the Librarian — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 10:50:31 PDT

Hanna Montana is one of the most annoying shows ever on television -- ever! It is more annoying than that one where the chimp was a detective -- and less watchable.

the Librarian

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Tenno — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 09:44:13 PDT

Hannah Does Montana!

OK, ok, I know. That's wrong. And too early.

Tenno

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Honeybhind — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 09:05:41 PDT

what's the hulabaloo - grand theft auto 4 is okay but god forbid a girl shows her back.

Honeybhind

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

dluvvly — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 06:42:16 PDT

How long until the nude Elizabeth Hasselback photos and/or sex tape make their way to the Internets? And at what age?

dluvvly

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

DexterRiley — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 05:25:47 PDT

@ObtuseIntolerant:
Good on you. Exactly; she's supposed to look like she just got nailed. And that's seriously wrong.
And let's not forget, despite all the excuse-making: technically, Daddy Cyrus as the guardian, broke the law here in California.

DexterRiley

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Scooter34 — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 04:41:55 PDT

It's not the pictures I object to - it's the Cyruses pitching Miley as a wholesome, good-for-you role model kind of girl, and then turning around and permitting suggestive pictures to be published in a national magazine. I had no problem with the Britney pics, nor Brooke Shields or AJ - they weren't selling all-American goodness.

At least they should wait until she's seventeen before trying to "glamorize" her image.

Scooter34

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

cinerama — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 02:31:59 PDT

Are Billy Ray and Miley's publicity folks really so daft as to not know that this would be the ultimate outcome of Leibovitz' suggestions?

Further, "take your clothes off and here's a sheet" should have been a slight clue.

Bottom line is it's not surprising Leibovitz posed these photos, but the question is, art or not, why they agreed to them.

Unless this is just the latest PR move to keep her empire rolling in dough so she can make the jump from Disney star to "real" actress in Hollywood.

cinerama

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

raincoaster — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 01:47:05 PDT

I'm not American. I was born in France, for god's sake. But this is supposed to be sexy. And she is topless. And you're not supposed to take sexy, topless photos of fifteen-year-olds.

It's. Just. Creepy.

raincoaster

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

CatherineTrammell — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 01:18:42 PDT

Not a big deal. She's just four years closer to marrying a back-up dancer, popping out two kids, shaving her head, having a nervous breakdown, and playing the girlfriend to some bitchy gay actor on a bad sitcom.

In four years we will look back on this and remember "the good old days."

CatherineTrammell

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

snowhite — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 23:13:57 PDT

To Annie: What's wrong with taking a NICE, AGE-APPROPRIATE photo of young girls? Why do you have to exploit them? As the older person, YOU should act more responsibly! For shame!
[z.about.com]

snowhite

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

ObtuseIntolerant — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 20:54:31 PDT

What's gross is she is 15, and she looks tousled and recently bedded...don't feign obtuseness, we all know what it infers. And it's for a magazine for grown-ups.

It does not bear comparison to the age-appropriate sensuality (yes, there is such a thing!!) of TigerBeat or the girl from the Cruella DeVil video.

We're sexual creatures from a young age. It's just a matter of how detailed you want to get, and how much you want to blur the lines between youthful sensuality and adult sexuality.

I think this crosses the line.

ObtuseIntolerant

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Little Mintz Sunshine — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 20:48:02 PDT

That fabric she's holding represents ten times the fabric I used to wear at her age when I mowed the lawn.

Little Mintz Sunshine

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

sastinson — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 20:32:50 PDT

Just like seeing a girl in a bathing suit is different than seeing her in her lingerie, it's not what she's showing, it's how she's showing it. I'm sure she bares more in lots of her concerts, or even on her Disney show, but that's a bed sheet, and that's bed hair. Those details and any number of others make this a Lolita shot.

Of course, I don't know that she necessarily needs a stern talking to, but I do think her dad does.

sastinson

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

charles_barrett — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 19:47:46 PDT

Not scandalous. Not licentious. Perhaps a bit avant garde for a provencial American teen from the fly-over states, but hell, Annie knows how to shoot a tasteful nude, and in this Miley in IN NO WAY nude. She has nothing to be embarrassed about. We puritanical 'murricans are the ones who ought to be "embarrassed and ashamed..."

charles_barrett

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Decebal — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 17:55:50 PDT

It's not the bare back, she looks like she just rolled off of the Jonas brothers. All three of them!!!

I must be getting old, but at 15 she does not need to look like a 30 year old woman. Can't she wait until she is 19 to look 30?

Decebal

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

WasatchMan — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 17:55:43 PDT

The girl from "The Ring."

WasatchMan

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

nick_r — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 16:30:52 PDT

BREAKING: MILEY CYRUS NUDE SCANDAL!!!

New allegations have surfaced suggesting that Miley Cyrus showers every morning completely nude. Representatives from Disney could not immediately be reached for comment.

nick_r

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

raincoaster — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:56:40 PDT

Oh, come on. Miley Cyrus looks like she just lived through "The Story of O" for god's sake. What happened after? Annie gave her a cigarette and her cell number? It's creepy.

Nothing wrong with the Teen Cover except the fact that Lohan already looked 30.

raincoaster

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

MsMuffinMcGuffin — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:55:55 PDT

She looks like one of those LIFETIME movies... "Tory, Portrait Of a Teenage Hooker" or something.

MsMuffinMcGuffin

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

mothrafairy — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:39:15 PDT

Oh...and Annie is an overrated boob.

mothrafairy

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

hughman — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:33:53 PDT

or a Les Miserables poster.

hughman

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Victor Ward — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:20:45 PDT

She looks like Linda Blair.

Victor Ward

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

Leviticus_71 — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 15:13:21 PDT

She looks like a Chris Isaak video.

Leviticus_71

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

NoWireHangers — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 14:58:19 PDT

In our post post post modern society where everything is a simulation and nothing is real/original anymore, the line between whore and starlet is too blurred to be discernible. Case in point the picture of Elliot Spitzer's prostitute clutching her breasts. Who did it first, the hooker or the pop tart? Who the hell knows anymore.

Just get drunk before your head explodes.

NoWireHangers

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

bess marvin, girl detective — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 14:55:52 PDT

i don't see anything sexual about the raining teens cover. okay, maybe mandy moore is eyefucking us, but the rest look fine to me.

hasn't Vanity Fair tired of Annie and her covers? the starlet group shots are only interesting to visit years later to see which ones made it and which ones fell.

bess marvin, girl detective

Investigating The Miley Cyrus 'Topless' Photo Scandal: Career-Ender Or Standard Starlet Move?

princessxenu — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 14:46:15 PDT

NOT a big deal. I think the big deal is that Disney has been grooming these kids to be totally sexy since day one. They have a 14 year old girl doing this sexy, pouty version of Cruella De Vil at the end of the new Dalmations video. I wouldn't let my kids watch it. This is tepid compared to her myspace photos. What a bunch of bullshit to sell magazines.

princessxenu